Day 8: A spring-like day sparks baseball debate

Today, three events reminded me  that spring is almost here. Daylight savings time, spring-like weather and my first Major League Baseball discussion of the season.  My friend and I revisited one of our most frequent disagreements about baseball – the designated hitter. I’m going to use my discussion to write a different genre (opinion) than I’ve written thus far for the challenge.

Major League baseball is the only professional sports league that changes its rules based upon the game’s location. Games played in American League (A.L.) Parks’ use a Designated Hitter where as games in National League (N.L.) Parks’ the pitcher bats. The National League must adopt the Designated Hitter rule.

First, There is now an interleague game every day. It used to be such games were played during a few week period every season. A.L. pitchers could prepare for these special games. Now, they are being put at a higher risk for injury by being asked to do what they hardly ever do — hit and run the bases — at various points throughout the entire season. At a time when teams are trying more and more to protect pitchers, it doesn’t make sense to put half the sport’s hurlers in this situation.

Next, The 15 NL teams simply cannot sign certain free agents to long-term contracts because they do not have the DH as a fallback position when the player ages and, perhaps, loses the ability to play the field. For example, David Ortiz cannot be signed by an NL team.

Lastly, most fans want to watch offense, not a sleepy 2-1 pitcher’s duel night after night. In the past four years, offense has cratered, and it was at its worst in 2014. Teams averaged 4.17 runs per game this year, lowest since 1989. The MLB batting average of .253 and on-base percentage of .318 were the lowest since 1972, the year before the AL introduced the DH.

American League teams are building their roster and allocating dollars to play one way all year, and then in World Series have to play a different way.

Having different rules does not make any sense. Just imagine, if a Super Bowl team playing one way all season is told in the Super Bowl they cannot play with a running back. It’s time for Major League Baseball to make the National League adopt the Designated Hitter.


6 thoughts on “Day 8: A spring-like day sparks baseball debate

  1. I really liked reading this and you know what a sports fanatic I am :). You know what I liked the most? You made sure those who don’t follow baseball will understand why your argument matters. I can’t wait for you to share this with your 4th graders! Ah Spring, so happy it has come our way.


  2. Well done, your opinion came through loud and clear. I can just imagine the intensity with which you and your friend discuss this every season. During my Spring break I travel to the Phoenix area for the delight of watching Spring training! I am going to venture a guess that you root for an American League team! Maybe your friend’s team is National league, like mine is.


  3. This will be a great piece to share with your students on how to write persuasive/opinion. I don’t follow baseball enough to know/understand/care about the DH rule but you brought it to me in a way that I understood. And thanks for the trivia bit as I never even knew that the rules were different depending on location!


  4. Strong piece! I wonder if you will use it as a mentor text when you teach opinion writing.
    I don’t have an opinion but my husband disagrees with you! some time I”d love to hear you two hash it out 🙂
    I particularly like your 3 signs of spring opening!


  5. Growing up my family watched a lot of baseball. If the Cincinnati Reds were playing, it was either on our TV or being announced on the radio. Not until I moved to another state and began watching another team did I realize that pitchers didn’t bat. I just assumed all major leagues teams did the same thing. I don’t feel as passionate as you do about this; however, I agree that to make things more even all teams need to play following the same rules all of the time. Can’t wait until the season really begins!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s